Berkeley Progressive Alliance

Home » 2016 (Page 2)

Yearly Archives: 2016

Results of Endorsement Meeting held by BPA- BCA-BTU on Saturday April 30th

Endorsement Results:

Mayor: Jesse Arreguin               District 2: Nanci Armstrong-Temple

District 3: Ben Bartlett                District 5: Sophie Hahn

District 6: Fred Dodsworth


Mayor: 109 valid ballots counted, one invalid. Jesse Arreguin achieved 60% threshhold on first round of rank choice counting

Jesse Arreguin 65%                         Kriss Worthington 24%

Mike Lee: 4%                                     Ben Gould: 3%

Write ins: 2 for Kate Harrison, 1 for Moni Law                                      No endorsement: 2%

Total votes for Jesse Arreguin for 1st, 2nd or 3rd choice: 97. Total votes for Kriss Worthington for 1st, 2nd or 3rd choice: 74


District 2 City Council – 98 valid ballots. Nanci Armstrong-Temple achieved 61% after ranked choices were counted

Nanci Armstrong-Temple: 61%          Cheryl Davila: 26%                      No Endorsement    13%


District 3 City Council – 103 valid ballots  (3 invalid ballots): Endorsement goes to Ben Bartlett, who achieved 87% on first round of rank choice counting

Ben Bartlett: 87%                                      Mark Coplan: 12%                      Deborah Matthews: 1%     No endorsement   0


District 5 City Council – 85 Valid ballots: Sophie Hahn achieved 78.9% on first round of rank choice counting

Sophie Hahn 91%                                   Stephen Murphy: 6%                    No endorsement: 2%


District 6 City Council – 94 valid ballots, 2 invalid: Fred Dodsworth achieved 78.9% on first round of rank choice counting

Fred Dodsworth: 78%                                  Isabelle Gaston: 9%                 Susan Wengraf: 5%         No Endorsement: 9%

Ten Candidates Seek Our Endorsement! 

These Ten Candidates have submitted questionnaires about their candidacy and will speak at the April 30th Endorsement Meeting. Join us Saturday April 30th from 1:30 to 5 at the Youth Adult Project (YAP) at 1730 Oregon Street. Click here to download the current flyer.

To vote in the endorsement meeting you must be a member of BPA or Berkeley Citizens Action or the Berkeley Tenants Union by April 24th. Each group will have membership lists at the registration tables at the event. Members can bring dues current there. No one will be turned away due to lack of funds. If needed, as during registration.

All candidates who are registered with the city or requested consideration were sent the following questionnaire. Do Candidates support our Progressive Agenda & Housing Platform? See their responses summarized here (We apologize for omitting Mark Coplan’s responses in the matrix, the corrected document is now posted). Below you may click on candidates name’s to access their full responses.

Mayor:  Jesse Arreguin    Ben Gould     Mike Lee    Kriss Worthington

City Council District 2:  Cheryl K. Davila        Nanci Armstrong-Temple

City Council District 3:   Ben Bartlett              Mark Coplan

City Council District 5:   Sophie Hahn

City Council District 6:   Fred Dodsworth

Click here for Draft Voting Rules and Ballots. This will be updated when finalized.

The following local measures are under way for the November 2016 ballot: Local measures & Rent Board Slate Update.

Endorse Progressive Candidates for Mayor and Council on Saturday April 30, 1:30-5pm


The Berkeley Progressive Alliance (BPA) and Berkeley Citizens Action (BCA) are holding a joint meeting to endorse candidates for Mayor and for Council Districts 2 (Southwest Berkeley), 3 (South Berkeley), 5 (North Berkeley) and 6 (Northeast Berkeley hills).

Meeting Location: The Young Adult Project (YAP) Recreation Center’s gymnasium, 1730 Oregon Street. YAP is located below MLK on Oregon, next to baseball diamond, near the Tarea Hall Pittman (South Branch) Library.

When: Saturday, April 30th. Registration 1:30 pm. Meeting: 2-5 pm

This year’s local election will take place on November 8, 2016, the same day as the federal and state elections. This is an important election. We hope to elect a progressive majority to Berkeley’s City Council.

At the meeting you’ll hear from candidates for Berkeley City Council and Mayor; vote to select the best of these candidates for endorsement; discuss measures which maybe on the November ballot; and plan election campaigning. Endorsed candidates will receive support from BCA and BPA in their campaigns.

To vote at our endorsement meeting, you must be a member of either BCA or BPA by April 24. You may not join either organization on the day of the meeting if you wish to vote. Everyone gets one vote, even if you are a member of both organizations. Find instructions for joining at end of this announcement.

Candidates: If you are running for City Council or Mayor, or are seriously thinking about running, and would like our endorsement, contact us by e-mail at,  or BCA at  Candidates will be asked to complete a questionnaire. Completed questionnaires will be made available to members or BPA and BCA in advance of the meeting and will also be available at the meeting.

BCA Membership: Past BCA members can pay at the door or online. Membership is $35 yearly, $10 low income. If you wish to join BCA, click HERE to join online or send us your name, e-mail address, street address, phone and payment to: Berkeley Citizens Action, PO Box 0032, Berkeley, CA  94709 by April 24th. For more information about BCA, visit:

BPA Membership: BPA is a new organization. To join, send your name, e-mail address, street address and phone (optional), and your City Council district if you know it, and your first year’s dues, $10 to:  Berkeley Progressive Alliance, PO Box 2961, Berkeley, CA 94702. If you are a member by April 24, but have yet not paid dues, you may pay at the meeting (by check  or cash).
Membership in the Berkeley Progressive Alliance is open to any resident of Berkeley who is supportive of our mission statement and in general agreement with our agenda, which is a work in progress. Affordable housing is one of the key issues we are working on. Take a look at our Affordable Housing Platform on our website.
For more information about BPA, visit:

If you have questions, e-mail us at or

Follow-up to 3/6 Housing for the Rest of Us


It was a tremendous event, more than 125 people attended Housing for the Rest of Us and heard Don Goldmacher introduce BPA and Kate Harrison present our housing platform. Max Anderson spoke of the housing situation and Ben Bartlett shared his agenda for addressing housing inequity in Berkeley. John Selawsky announced the Tenant Convention and landlord tax, Sophie Hanh, Jesse Arreguin, Kriss Worthington and many others shared their ideas. Here are some photos and links to articles about the event.  Stay tuned for ways to get involved in creating and protecting housing for the 99%, especially for the lowest income residents of Berkeley.

Daily Cal- Berkeley Progressive Alliance presents affordable housing platform

Contra Costa Times- Berkeley progressives call for affordable housing, new leadership

Daily Cal- Housing crisis demands attention from state, campus

Housing for the Rest of Us: Introducing the Berkeley Progressive Alliance and their Affordable Housing Platform

Sunday, March 6th, 2 to 4:30 pm, South Berkeley Senior Center
2939 Ellis Street at Ashby

Oxford Plaza downtown Berkeley.jpg

Oxford Plaza, energy efficient affordable housing built in 2009 at a comfortable scale. Since 2009, almost no affordable housing has been built, for lack of committed funding for the Berkeley Housing Trust Fund

There is a solution to the Affordable Housing Crisis

Berkeley could build a hundred units of affordable housing a year, if we raise funds for the Housing Trust Fund. Hear about practical solutions that will raise the money needed. Prepare for the 2016 Election by making plans to elect a mayor, city council members, and rent board commissioners who will represent all of us, not just the 1%. Speakers include:

  • Max Anderson ‐ Berkeley City Councilmember District 3 (South Berkeley)
  • Ben Bartlett ‐ member, Berkeley Planning Commission and District 3 City Council candidate
  • Kate Harrison, Berkeley Progressive Alliance and National State Politics chair of the Wellstone Democratic Renewal Club
  • Community Organizers to update us on the upcoming 2016 Berkeley Tenant Convention, Minimum Wage efforts, the Proposed Landlord Tax and Public Campaign Financing

Refreshments and childcare provided (RSVP for childcare to:

Sponsored by: Berkeley Progressive Alliance, Berkeley Citizens Action, Better Berkeley Working Group, Berkeley Tenants Union, and Grassroots House

Berkeley Progressive Alliance          Join us on Facebook          Phone: (510) 863-1223   

P.O. Box  2961, Berkeley, CA 94709          Email:

Affordable Housing Platform


Since 2011, rents for vacant rent controlled apartments have soared by an average of 47% and are unaffordable to many of the people who live and work here. Housing costs impact our city’s vitality and diversity by contributing to the decline of the African American population and fewer lower-income residents and creative people. Berkeley has fallen short of building the new housing called for under regional housing goals and falls woefully short of housing affordable by moderate and low income households. This problem is not unique to Berkeley: Oakland, San Francisco and most of the Bay Area face a housing affordability crisis. We need a comprehensive approach in Berkeley.

Build More Affordable Housing

More housing is needed for people at all income levels with the greatest need for housing affordable to low and moderate income households:

  1. Prioritize affordable housing by streamlining permitting process for projects with at least 50% affordable units.
  2. Use some Housing Trust Fund money to purchase existing rental housing to keep it affordable and develop ownership opportunities through limited equity coops.
  3. Evaluate publicly owned sites for suitability for housing. Develop the Berkeley Way parking lot and North Berkeley BART air rights for affordable housing.
  4. Build more housing for students at locations close to the UC campus as called for in the Southside Plan. Work with the Berkeley Student Cooperative to expand relatively affordable co-op housing.

Increase Funding

Every dollar in the Trust Fund can leverage about $3 in federal or other public funds to build affordable housing. There are four actions the City Council should take to generate more funds for the City’s Housing Trust Fund to pay for additional affordable housing:

  1. Ask voters to increase the business license tax on large landlords in Berkeley; each 1% increase in the tax would bring in $2 to $3 million annually, a small proportion of the estimated $66 million that rents have increased in Berkeley since 2011.
  2. Increase Housing Impact fees to at least $34,000 as recommended by a City-commissioned study and make funds available earlier by requiring developers to pay the fee when the first construction document is issued. If a developer chooses to build housing on site instead of paying the fee, require it to provide 20% affordable units (5 affordable units for every 20 market rate units).
  3. Tax short term rentals like AirBnB and place the money in the Housing Trust Fund.
  4. Allocate 25% of excess Property Transfer Tax Funds to the Housing Trust Fund.

Together, these actions could generate $10 million or more and fund creation of around 100 or more affordable units each year through both new construction and acquisition of existing housing. Some of these funds could also be used to create affordable home ownership via limited equity coops and other resident-controlled cooperative housing.

Maintain the Supply of Existing Rental Housing

We also need to insure that currently affordable housing is not taken off market. Ask the Council to:

  1. Strengthen our Demolition Ordinance. Require that each rent controlled unit be replaced one for one with housing permanently affordable to low wage people.
  2. Prohibit conversion of rent controlled units to short term rentals.
  3. Create a City-maintained waiting list for affordable housing units and work to give priority for these units to those who currently live or work in Berkeley.
  4. Continue to limit conversion of rental units to condominiums and increase the conversion fee.
  5. Continue Support for Rent and Eviction Controls.
  6. Lobby for changes to state law to allow rent control for new housing beginning ten years after it’s built.
  7. Monitor Ellis Act evictions after they happen to insure evictions were legal and increase relocation fees for owner move-in evictions.
  8. Regularly monitor habitability of affordable and rent controlled units to insure they are retained in the housing stock, with inspections paid for by the owners.

Build Green, Sustainable Buildings

Reduce the generation of greenhouse gases and water use by residential buildings in Berkeley:

  1. Require new multi-family housing in Berkeley to meet a Zero Net Energy standard by 2020. Solar electric and solar thermal systems should become commonplace.
  2. Require best-practice water conservation measures in new buildings.
  3. Require all developers including in the downtown to pay open space impact fees to create and maintain parks, plazas, community gardens, etc.
  4. Require developers to pay transportation service fees to support pedestrian, bicycle and transit improvements and incentives.
  5. Encourage developers to seek GreenTRIP certification from Transform through car-sharing, transit passes for residents, and ample bicycle parking and storage.
  6. Give incentives to homeowners and owners of existing multi-family housing to make energy efficiency and water conservation improvements.


In 2010, Berkeley had about 27,183 rental housing units, an increase from 24,512 units in 1990. Of these, about 19,000 are rent-controlled housing units. State law in 1995 replaced Berkeley’s system of strong rent control with vacancy decontrol, which means that landlords can raise their rent to market rate whenever a unit becomes vacant.

Rents are soaring

In the last few years, rents for new tenancies in rent controlled units have risen sharply:

New tenancies                       2011                    2015 Jan-Sept                          change

Studio                                     $ 970                         $1,450                                    + 49.5%

One bedroom                     $1,250                          $1,800                                    + 44.0%

Two-bedroom                      $1,700                       $2,600                                    + 52.9%

Source: Data in Berkeley Rent Stabilization Board, December 14, 2015 Memorandum, Market Medians: January 1999 through September 2015 http:// Rent_Stabilization_Board/Level_3_-_General/3q2015_Market_Medians.pdf

Average rents in new apartment are now much higher than rents in older rent controlled housing. Average rents in new apartment buildings in Berkeley as of 2014 were:

One-bedroom:     $2,537

Two-bedrooms: $3,434

Source: bae urban economics, City of Berkeley Affordable Housing Nexus Study, March 25, 2015, p. 4. 

What is affordable?

Federal guidelines set 30% of household income spent on housing as the limit for determining whether housing is affordable. If more than 30% goes for housing and utilities, then it’s not affordable.

Many tenant households in Berkeley have modest incomes. 82% of renter households have income below $100,000 a year, making area rents for even a studio unaffordable:

Median household income, renters:  $ 38,539          Affordable monthly rent: $963

Median income of renters is even lower in South and West Berkeley. In South Berkeley, median tenant household incomes are under $38,000 a year.

Source: 2010-2014 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, S2503, Financial Characteristics, data by Census tracts and for the city as a whole. South Berkeley defined as Census tracts 4233, 4234, and 4240.

What kind of housing is currently being built in Berkeley?

Berkeley’s General Plan calls for the City to create 6,400 permanently affordable units for low- and very-low-income households. Between 2007 and 2014, only 22 units were produced for people with moderate incomes, achieving only 4% of Regional Fair Share Goal. Only 87 low income units and 76 very low income units were built in Berkeley, achieving only 21% and 23% respectively of Berkeley’s regional fair share goal.

More than 1,000, or 84%, of housing units produced in Berkeley were affordable only to people with above moderate incomes (income greater than 120% of the area median income, or income in excess of $112,200 in 2015 in Alameda County).

Source: City of Berkeley 2015-2023 Housing Element. For area median income: California Department of Housing and Community Development Division of Housing Policy Development, “State Income Limits for 2015”, April 15, 2015.

Many families pay more rent than they can afford 

Only a fraction of low income families in Berkeley receive Section 8 housing vouchers or live in permanently affordable housing. Of Berkeley’s nearly 50,000 housing units, only about 2,000 are subsidized or inclusionary units. Up to 2,000 people in Berkeley have Section 8 or Shelter Plus Care vouchers.

Now, 53.5% of Berkeley’s renters are currently paying 30% or more or their income in rent. A City’s Rent Board survey of tenants in rent-controlled housing in 2009 found that 26% of non-student tenants were paying more than 50% of their income in rent, up from 20% in 1998. About 3,400 Berkeley households are considered “extremely rent burdened”. Rents have soared since 2009; those paying over 50% of income in rent have also increased.

Students, who make up about one-third of the City’s tenant population also face a difficult situation. Even with a big jump in UC fees, many students’ housing costs are still higher than their fees. This contributes to their debt when they leave school. Even though many students double up, they still pay high rent even when they share rooms.

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, 2010-2014 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates; Berkeley Rent Stabilization Board, Rent Stabilization and the Berkeley Rental Housing Market 15 Years after Vacancy Decontrol, January 28,2013; Stephen Barton, Ph.D., and former City of Berkeley Housing director, “Berkeley’s Affordable Housing Crisis and What We Can Do About It”, PowerPoint presentation for November 22 teach-in].

What is the City Council doing to address the housing affordability crisis?

At the moment, not much.

The Council Rejected a Modest Budget Request

In April, 2015, the City Council rejected a proposal from Councilmembers Anderson, Arreguin and Worthington to add $1 million to the Housing Trust Fund as part of the current budget. Funds are available: the City collected close to $164 million in discretionary revenue in 2015, up from $140 million five years earlier.

… and Discounted the Housing Fee to Benefit a Big Developer

In April 2015, the City Council continued discounting the housing impact fee to $20,000, down from the $28,000 approved in 2012. They took this action just as the largest housing project ever proposed in Berkeley was being considered and despite clear evidence that rents, and developer revenues, are soaring. Councilmembers Anderson, Arreguin and Worthington dissented. The City Council still has not acted to update the fee based on a March 2015 study recommending a $34,000 per unit fee and noting that construction of 100 market rate units creates demand for 25 additional low and moderate income units.

Source (revenue) City of Berkeley Adopted Biennial Budget, Fiscal Years 2016 & 2017, p. 40; for HTF budget referral: April 7 City Council Agenda, item 33, “Budget Referral: Housing Trust Fund”; for Council vote on impact fees: http:// Clerk/City_Council/2015/04_Apr/City_Council__04-07-2015_-_Regular_Meeting_Annotated_Agenda.aspx; sources: [site under construction]; bae urban economics, City of Berkeley Affordable Housing Nexus Study, March 25, 2015

Housing Trust Fund: Running Near Empty

The amount needed to complete projects already identified by affordable housing developers by 2018 is as much as $ 36.8 million. As a result of the Council’s failure to act, the City has relatively little money available in the Housing Trust Fund. As of November 5, 2015, the Trust Fund had a balance of only $3,067,578.

Source: “Below Market Rate Housing and Housing Trust Fund Program Status” prepared by city staff for City Council Work Session, December 1, 2015 (item 03). Funding Strategies:

Building it Green

The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) adopted the California Long Term Energy Efficiency Strategic Plan, calling for all new residential construction in California to be Zero Net Energy (ZNE) by 2020. A ZNE building produces as much energy as it consumes during a year through energy efficiency and clean, on-site renewable power generation, typically solar photovoltaics.

The CPUC and at the California Energy Commission staff’s New Residential Zero Net Energy Action Plan 2015-2020 makes the state’s 2020 ZNE goal possible. Berkeley requires new buildings downtown to be LEED gold, but this can be achieved without any on-site energy generation and does not necessarily lead to much reduction in the building’s carbon footprint. Very few new Berkeley buildings have any significant solar energy component (Oxford Plaza downtown and Helios Corner on University are notable exceptions).

New development can also help achieve the City’s Climate Action Plan goals if buildings are located near transit and residents received encouragement and incentives to take transit, walk and bike; Transform’s Green Trip certification can help with that.


Drafted for the BPA by Rob Wrenn and Kate Harrison


Berkeley Progressive Alliance Newsletter #1

Newsletter #1, February 2016

Dear Affordable Housing Activist,

This is the inaugural newsletter of the Berkeley Progressive Alliance (BPA). You are receiving it because you attended the affordable housing TEACH-IN on November 22, 2015, or are part of the Sustainable Berkeley Coalition.

Mission Statement

The Berkeley Progressive Alliance works for open, transparent, and fair governance that supports our diverse community with appropriate development projects, reasonably priced housing, policies that protect the environment and equitable public education. Individuals, neighborhood groups, social justice and environmental justice organizations are invited to join us.

As we all are acutely aware, this is an election year both nationally and locally. For the past 12 years we have seen Berkeley transformed into Speculation City, with such amenities as the Shattuck Cinemas, Habitot, and treasured local businesses threatened with demolition, and the cost of housing soaring. While there are new apartment buildings constructed all over Berkeley, they are renting at exorbitant market rates and include few low-income or family units. They are not built to high energy-efficiency and water conservation standards.

All of these changes have been presided over by Mayor Tom Bates and his City Council majority, who seem to represent the interests of speculative developers and investors rather than those of Berkeley residents.

BPA is committed to electing a   progressive mayor and a City Council majority that will be accountable to the residents of Berkeley, not to a handful of large real estate speculators, such as the Blackstone Private Equity Corporation, owner of the now infamous Library Gardens.

We need you to be a part of our efforts. Specifically, we are establishing working committees of the alliance, and we welcome your participation in one or more of them.

1. Voter Registration: To be successful, we need to register new voters and those who have given up on voting. We know that when there is greater voter turnout, there is a greater likelihood of progressive issues and candidates winning. If you would like to be part of this effort, please join our voter engagement/outreach committee.

2. Outreach:  The ability to reach our progressive base depends in part on our ability to produce all sorts of media and communications that will engage our voter base. They include the use of social media on the Internet, producing and distributing leaflets and flyers at community events and distribution at popular locations in the city, and creating short videos that can be used for house parties as well as on the Internet. If you have media experience, we welcome your participation in our media committee.

3.  Fundraising: To compete successfully in elections requires having adequate funds to produce flyers, pay for phone banks, produce campaign literature, etc. We are creating a fund-raising committee that will work to sponsor house parties where people can donate to the alliance. We need to encourage individuals to donate through our forthcoming website. Using house parties to raise money and educate voters in Berkeley requires organizers and speakers. Successful house parties not only produce funds to help in our efforts, but galvanize new people to participate in the democratic process.

If you feel as we do, that the local elections in Berkeley are critical in determining the future direction of our city, we invite you to participate in our growing organization and help move this city in a more progressive, sustainable direction. The future of our families, our children and grandchildren may well be determined by this year’s election.

Please tell us which of the above committee or committees you would like to participate in and email us at: It would also be helpful if you indicate your relevant skill sets or experience.

Follow us on Facebook at Berkeley Progressive Alliance.

Membership in BPA is $10 per year, and can be waived if necessary.

In Solidarity,

Interim Coordinating Committee of the Berkeley Progressive Alliance

Don Goldmacher and Kate Harrison, Co-Chairs.

“The question I wonder is after death, after my last breath
When will I finally get to rest? Through this oppression
They punish the people that’s asking questions
And those that possess, steal from the ones without possessions
The message I stress: to make it stop study your lessons
Don’t settle for less – even a genius ask questions
Be grateful for blessings
Don’t ever change, keep your essence
The power is in the people and politics we address”
― Tupac Amaru Shakur